Was Islam Spread by the Sword? What Scholars and Historians Say

Few questions about Islam are asked as often, or answered as loosely, as this one. Critics point to the speed of the early Arab conquests; some defenders reply that Islam spread only by preaching. Was Islam spread by the sword? A careful answer separates two things that the question runs together: the expansion of Muslim political rule, which did happen largely through military conquest, and the conversion of people to Islam, which Islamic law forbids forcing and which historians show happened slowly, over centuries, and mostly without compulsion. This guide sets out what the Quran says, how classical scholars such as Ibn Taymiyyah, Ibn al-Qayyim and Shaykh Ibn Baz understood the role of jihad, what historians such as Richard Bulliet and Richard Eaton found, where forced conversions did occur, and how Islam spread in regions no Muslim army conquered.

Was Islam Spread by the Sword? The Short Answer

Not in the sense that people were forced to believe. Was Islam spread by the sword in the sense that Muslim armies conquered territory? Yes, the early caliphate expanded through war, and classical Muslim scholars openly acknowledged that military strength supported the call to Islam. But Islamic law does not permit compelling anyone to convert, conquered Christians, Jews and Zoroastrians were allowed to keep their religion under a protection agreement (dhimmah), and conversion in the conquered lands took about three centuries. The historical picture can be summed up in one line: Islam was not spread by the sword, but without the sword it would not have spread. And in Indonesia, Malaysia, much of West and East Africa and parts of South Asia, where most of the world's Muslims live today, Islam spread largely without conquest.

Conquest vs Conversion: Why the Distinction Matters

The early Muslim conquests, beginning under the Rightly Guided Caliphs Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Ali, brought Iraq, Syria, Palestine, Egypt and Iran under Muslim rule within a few decades of the Prophet's death. That is a political and military fact. Conversion, however, is a change of belief, and the historical record shows it lagged far behind conquest. Conquest took a couple of decades, conversion took about three centuries. The Academy's Rightly Guided Caliphs Course covers the conquests of this period, their motives and their conduct in detail.

Conquest and Conversion by Region

Region How Islam arrived When Muslims became a majority What the evidence shows
Iraq and Iran Conquest in the 630s to 650s CE Iran reached about 50% only in the mid-9th century; Iraq a century before Egypt Slow conversion over two to three centuries (Bulliet)
Egypt Conquest in the 640s CE Around a century after Iraq; Muslims were about 10% of the population early on Christians kept their churches; conversion accelerated in the 9th and 10th centuries
Al-Andalus (Spain) Conquest from 711 CE Gradually, over centuries The 713 treaty with Christian rulers forbade forced conversion
Indian subcontinent Conquest in the north; trade and preaching in other areas Never a majority overall Fewest Muslims in the heartland of Muslim rule, most in frontier regions such as Bengal and Punjab (Eaton)
Southeast Asia and West Africa Not significantly conquered by Muslim armies Over many centuries Spread without "the sword"

The figures draw on the research of historians such as Richard Bulliet and Richard Eaton, and the conquest dates are standard historical dates.

What the Quran Says About Compulsion in Religion

"There Is No Compulsion in Religion"

The central verse is in Surah al-Baqarah:

﴿ لَآ إِكْرَاهَ فِى ٱلدِّينِ ۖ قَد تَّبَيَّنَ ٱلرُّشْدُ مِنَ ٱلْغَىِّ ﴾

"There shall be no compulsion in [acceptance of] the religion. The right course has become clear from the wrong." (Quran 2:256)

Ibn Kathir explained this verse: Islam is clear enough in its proofs that no one needs to be forced into it. The verse also shows that Islam does not compel conversion and that non-Muslims who decline it may remain on their faith under a dhimmah contract.

"Invite to the Way of Your Lord With Wisdom"

﴿ ٱدْعُ إِلَىٰ سَبِيلِ رَبِّكَ بِٱلْحِكْمَةِ وَٱلْمَوْعِظَةِ ٱلْحَسَنَةِ ۖ وَجَـٰدِلْهُم بِٱلَّتِى هِىَ أَحْسَنُ ﴾

"Invite to the way of your Lord with wisdom and good instruction, and argue with them in a way that is best." (Quran 16:125)

The Verses on Fighting

The Quran also contains verses commanding fighting, including 9:5 and 9:29, the verse of the jizyah. The Quran supports extending Muslim political authority over non-Muslims but does not authorise compulsory conversion. The jizyah verse itself assumes that non-Muslims remain non-Muslims: it sets the terms on which they live under Muslim rule, not a demand that they convert.

What Classical Muslim Scholars Said

Ibn Baz: Spread by Da'wah, Supported by the Sword

Shaykh Abd al-Aziz ibn Baz (Majmu' Fatawa wa Maqalat, vol. 6, p. 277) said that the claim that Islam spread by the sword is false when stated absolutely. Islam spread through calling people to Allah (da'wah), and the sword supported and enforced that call. He pointed out that the Prophet ﷺ called people to Islam in Makkah for thirteen years before fighting was prescribed, and continued to do so in Madinah before the command to fight came. He cited Surah al-Hadid (57:25), on iron containing great strength and benefit for people, and Surah al-Anfal (8:39), on fighting until there is no more fitnah.

Jihad Removed the Barriers to Da'wah

Classical scholars argued that jihad of conquest (jihad at-talab), together with preaching, was a major factor in the spread of Islam. Ibn Taymiyyah said that the religion is established by the Book and the sword, and Ibn al-Qayyim said that the Prophet ﷺ was sent with the Book as a guide and the sword as a helper. Crucially, the purpose of jihad was to remove the obstacles, namely hostile rulers and armies, that prevented people from hearing Islam and choosing it freely, not to force belief into anyone's heart.

Invite First, Then Jizyah, Then Fighting

A hadith records that the Prophet ﷺ instructed his commanders to first invite an enemy to Islam; if they refused, to offer them the option of paying the jizyah and keeping their religion; and only if they refused both, to fight. Islamic law describes the same three options and stresses that even defeated opponents were not to be forcibly converted. This structure is the opposite of forced conversion: it gives the conquered a recognised right to stay in their own faith.

The Prophet's own example is the starting point for all of this, from the patient years of preaching in Makkah to the treaties and campaigns in Madinah. The Academy's Sirah (Prophet Muhammad) Course follows that history step by step.

What Historians Found About Conversion

Muslims Were a Small Minority

The Arab armies were small, and Arab Muslims formed only around 10 percent of Egypt's population and around 20 percent in Iraq after the conquests. Forcing mass conversion on such large populations would have been impractical. The historian Hugh Kennedy makes the same point.

Conversion Took Centuries

Richard Bulliet's statistical work on conversion shows that non-Muslims remained the majority in the conquered lands for more than two centuries. Iran reached roughly 50 percent Muslim only in the mid-ninth century, and by about the year 1000 Muslims probably formed a majority in the central Middle East, with Iraq reaching that point roughly a century before Egypt.

The Jizyah Gave Rulers a Reason Not to Push Conversion

A practical incentive worked against forced conversion: the jizyah paid by non-Muslims was an important source of state revenue, so some governments had financial reasons not to encourage conversion. In 840 CE an official was even recorded forbidding Muslim missionaries in one region.

Treaties Protected Churches and Synagogues

The treaty attributed to Umar ibn al-Khattab with Sophronius, the patriarch of Jerusalem, and the 713 CE agreement in Spain both promised that the local Christians would not be forced to convert. The surviving text of Umar's treaty was written down about 250 years later, so its exact wording is uncertain, but it is clear that Christians kept possession of their churches. Under the Umayyads too, Christians, Zoroastrians, Jews and Sabians kept their worship and their own communal courts.

Why People Did Convert

Several pressures and attractions did lead people to Islam: it was the religion of the ruling elite, conversion brought social and career opportunities, it freed a person from the jizyah, and it eased movement into the growing Muslim towns. There were also later restrictions on dhimmis under the Abbasid caliph al-Mutawakkil in the 850s, a form of non-violent pressure that may not have been consistently enforced. The overall picture is that the government did not force conversion but that the structure of society encouraged it, and that Islam spread more by attracting people than by actively reaching out to them. The legal and social life of non-Muslim communities in Muslim societies is one of the topics of the Academy's Islamic Civilization Course.

Did Forced Conversions Ever Happen?

Yes, and an honest answer has to say so. Historians who argue strongly against the "sword" narrative acknowledge that some forced conversions likely occurred, particularly in parts of South Asia. It gives examples: the persecution of dhimmis under the Fatimid caliph al-Hakim in Egypt, the Ottoman devshirme system of taking Christian boys for state service, and the Orphans' Decree of Imam Yahya in twentieth-century Yemen. These were exceptions, often driven by politics rather than religion, and contrary to Islamic teaching, and it would be wrong to replace one simplistic story with another by claiming that force never played any role. Recognising these cases is part of telling the history accurately; they do not change the overall pattern of slow, largely voluntary conversion.

Where Islam Spread Without Conquest

South Asia: The Frontier, Not the Heartland

Richard Eaton's analysis of census data found the fewest Muslims in the Gangetic Plain, the heartland of centuries of Muslim rule in India, and the most in frontier regions such as Bengal and Punjab. If military rule had driven conversion, the pattern would be the reverse.

Southeast Asia and Africa

Southeast Asia and West Africa were not significantly conquered by Muslim armies. Indonesia, today the country with the largest Muslim population in the world, adopted Islam over several centuries through contact with merchants and scholars, as did the Swahili coast of East Africa and much of West Africa.

The Early Example of Madinah

Before any battle was fought, Islam had already spread to Madinah through preaching. After the pledges of al-Aqabah, the Prophet ﷺ sent the Companion Mus'ab ibn Umayr to teach the people there, and much of the city had embraced Islam before the Prophet emigrated in 622 CE.

Why the "Spread by the Sword" Claim Persists

The polemic can be traced from the Crusades through the writings of colonial-era Orientalists to modern Islamophobic discourse, and historians who challenged it include Sir Thomas Arnold in The Preaching of Islam (1896), De Lacy O'Leary, Marshall Hodgson and Ira Lapidus. Interestingly, some scholars criticise Arnold's book from the other direction, arguing that it downplays the real role of jihad. Both critiques point to the same conclusion: the full picture includes both conquest and da'wah.

This is one of several recurring claims about Islam, alongside questions such as why did Prophet Muhammad marry Aisha, that need answers grounded in the sources rather than in slogans. The Academy's Refutations of Misconceptions about Islam Course addresses these questions systematically.

Frequently Asked Questions

Final Thoughts

Was Islam spread by the sword? The sources together give a clearer answer than either slogan. Muslim rule spread through conquest, and Muslim scholars never hid that; faith itself, by Islamic law and by the historical record, was not imposed. Conquered peoples kept their churches and synagogues, conversion took centuries, and most of today's Muslims live in lands that no Muslim army conquered. People chose Islam for its beliefs, its community and its message, a question explored further in the Academy's article is Islam the true path.

References and Resources